Selling a Florida Home With an Old Roof: Insurance Rules, Inspections and Your Options

Selling

Oct 24

Quick answer: You can sell a Florida home with an old roof, but your buyer has to be able to insure it, and that is the question the negotiation turns on. Under s. 627.7011(5), an insurer may not refuse a policy solely because of roof age when the roof is under 15 years old, or when a roof 15 or older passes an inspection by an inspector the insurer approves showing 5 or more years of useful life left. Citizens Property Insurance wants documentation of at least five years of remaining life for shingle-type roofs older than 25 years and tile or metal roofs older than 50, and a September 11, 2025 Citizens bulletin lets a buyer apply on a purchase when a signed contract shows a full replacement within 30 days of the requested coverage date. Neither set of rules promises coverage. Your options are to replace before listing, get a roof inspection, offer a credit or price for the roof. A licensed insurance agent and a licensed roofing contractor should confirm the facts for your house.

If you are selling a Treasure Coast house with an older roof, the first question is not whether it leaks but whether your buyer can insure it, and that answer can decide whether the contract survives the inspection period.

Why does my buyer's insurance drive an old-roof negotiation?

The Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract (ASIS-7x) gives the buyer an inspection period "(if left blank, then 15)" days. If the property is unacceptable "in Buyer's sole discretion," the buyer may cancel by written notice and "the Deposit paid shall be returned to Buyer"; if not, "Buyer accepts the physical condition of the Property" (paragraph 12(a)). The form puts no general repair obligation on you, so a repair happens only if you agree to it in writing. (Paragraph 12(c) does require you to cooperate, without having to spend money, if the buyer finds an open or needed building permit, such as an unfinaled roof permit.)

The form has no general insurance contingency (paragraph 19 lists an optional "Homeowners'/Flood Ins" rider, which I did not review), so the inspection period is your buyer's main exit, and what the buyer's insurer says during it comes back to you as a request. After it, whether an insurance problem lets a buyer out depends on the contract; ask a Florida real estate attorney.

Under s. 627.7011(5)(b), an insurer may not refuse to issue or renew a homeowner's policy on a roof less than 15 years old "solely because of the age of the roof." For a roof 15 or older, (5)(c) requires the insurer to allow an inspection by an authorized inspector (one the insurer approves), at the homeowner's expense, before requiring replacement, and bars refusal "solely because of roof age" if the inspection shows 5 years or more of useful life remaining. It does not say what happens below 5 years.

Roof age runs from "the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced," or, when a series of partial replacements eventually covers the whole roof, from the first of them (5)(d). A repair or a single partial replacement does not reset it. The buyer's side is in buying a Florida home with an old roof.

What does Citizens require, and at what roof age?

Citizens Property Insurance publishes its roof rules; other insurers can apply their own within the statute. Citizens "requires a four-point inspection for all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for properties more than 20 years old." Shingle and similar roofs older than 25 years, and tile, slate, clay, concrete or metal roofs older than 50, "require documentation showing at least five years of remaining useful life." With less than five years left, "the property owner must provide proof of a full-roof replacement to the inspector before any policy is written."

A March 31, 2023 Citizens bulletin raised the minimum remaining life from 3 years to 5 (effective May 1, 2023 for new business and September 1, 2023 for renewals), ages a roof that was not replaced all at once by its oldest part, and accepts a finalized roof permit or a paid-in-full contract, work order or receipt as proof of replacement.

Can my buyer get insured if the roof still needs replacing?

A September 11, 2025 Citizens bulletin allows an unbound application (one submitted before coverage is bound) when the purchase occurs "within 45 calendar days of the effective date of coverage requested on the application" and a signed contract with a licensed contractor shows "a full roof replacement will be completed within 30 calendar days of the requested effective date of coverage." The exception "is independent and does not satisfy or affect any other eligibility requirements," and "Underwriting has a 60-day discovery period." If the rest of the application qualifies, that can turn a roof that might stop a sale into a question of who pays for the replacement.

Which inspection reports will a buyer ask for?

Report	What it covers	How long it is good for
Four-point inspection, Citizens form Insp4pt 03 25	"the roof, electrical, HVAC and plumbing systems," with photos and fields for "Roof age (years):" and "Remaining useful life (years):"	The form states no period. The Florida CFO's undated guide says that "generally" it "must be dated within the 30 days prior to the insurance application submission date," and each insurer sets its own timeframe.
Roof inspection form, Citizens RCF-1 03 25	Citizens' roof form; it "must be completed and signed by a Florida-licensed professional"	Not stated in what I reviewed.
Wind mitigation, OIR-B1-1802, effective April 1, 2026 (Rev. 04/26 in Citizens' bulletin)	The state's uniform mitigation verification inspection form	"valid for up to five (5) years provided no material changes are made to the structure" (Office of Insurance Regulation). Citizens accepts the older Rev. 01/12 form if completed within five years before April 1, 2026 and the structure has not changed (bulletin of March 19, 2026).

If I repair part of my roof, do I have to replace all of it?

Not always; it turns on whether the roof was built or last replaced to the 2007 Florida Building Code or later, which Citizens tests by the permit date. A replacement on a site-built single-family home must add secondary water barriers and roof-deck attachment upgrades (s. 553.844(3)(a), 2026 edition). In the wind-borne debris region, (3)(b) adds roof-to-wall connections for homes insured for $300,000 or more (or by just value if uninsured or the insured value is undocumented), but only if connections at gable ends or all corners can be done for 15 percent of the cost of the roof replacement.

The repair rule is subsection (5), added by ch. 2022-269. If the roof was built, repaired or replaced to "the 2007 Florida Building Code, or any subsequent editions," and 25 percent or more is repaired, replaced or recovered, "only the repaired, replaced, or recovered portion" must meet the code in effect. A Citizens claims job aid dated January 5, 2023 totals damage over 12 months and uses March 1, 2009, when the 2007 code took effect, as the permit-date test for single-family homes. For a roof permitted before that date with more than 25 percent of a roof section damaged, the job aid says "the entire roof will need to be replaced." A licensed roofing contractor can tell you where your roof stands.

Roof permits in Port St. Lucie

The city's post-storm permitting guide says "Roof replacements or substantial repairs" need a permit and "Temporary roof tarping" does not. St. Lucie County's undated roofing procedure says "A permit is required for any reroof work exceeding 25% of the existing roof area within a 12-month period." I did not confirm whether the county procedure applies inside the city, or research Martin or Indian River County; ask the building department.

Can My Safe Florida Home help before I sell?

Under s. 215.5586 (2026 edition), grants require, among other conditions, a homestead, a home built before January 1, 2008, an insured value of $700,000 or less, and a "low-income person or moderate-income person." The match is "$1 provided by the applicant for $2 provided by the state," up to "a maximum state contribution of $10,000"; low-income applicants may receive up to $10,000 with no match. Roof work includes roof-to-wall connections, roof-deck attachments and secondary water resistance, with a roof covering only "when necessary to complete approved installation of secondary water resistance for the roof" (SB 1452, 2026). Some 2026 changes to the program are set to expire July 1, 2027. I did not confirm 2026 funding or timing.

Replace, inspect, credit or price it in?

Option	What it does for the buyer's insurance	What it asks of you	What to watch
Replace before listing	Roof age starts over (s. 627.7011(5)(d)), and a finalized permit is proof Citizens accepts.	The cost, including the s. 553.844(3) upgrades, and time for the permit.	Get the permit finaled before you list.
Roof inspection or certification	Five or more years of remaining life meets Citizens' rule and, if the buyer's insurer approves the inspector, the statute's threshold for roofs 15 and older.	A licensed professional's inspection, and a plan if the answer is under five years.	The result becomes something you know; the buyer's insurer may want a newer report.
Offer a credit	Leaves replacement to the buyer, which Citizens allows on a purchase under the September 11, 2025 bulletin's conditions.	Agreeing on the amount, in writing.	Ask the buyer's lender how a credit is handled; have an attorney review the wording.
Price for it	Nothing; the buyer still needs a policy on the roof as it is.	An asking price that reflects the roof's age.	The buyer can still cancel during the inspection period.

The same choice comes up with older air conditioners; see selling a Florida home with an aging AC. If you use the Florida Realtors seller's disclosure form (the SPDR-4 redline I reviewed), it asks "To your knowledge, is the roof structurally sound and free of leaks?" and "Has the roof ever leaked during your ownership?" Answer from your records, and ask a Florida real estate attorney what you must disclose. Before you call me, gather:

The permit for the last full roof replacement, and whether it was finaled.
The roof material (shingle, tile or metal).
Invoices and dates for any roof repairs, leaks or partial replacements.
Any wind mitigation, four-point or roof report, and any insurer letter about the roof.

What I could not confirm

I have not found a primary source with roof replacement costs or permit fees that I can cite, so this article gives no cost figures. I quoted the ASIS-7x redline; read the same paragraphs in the version you sign. I left out FHA and VA roof rules, which I could not verify; ask the buyer's lender. Citizens' bulletins may not reflect later changes, so have a licensed insurance agent confirm the rules when your buyer applies.

Your buyer's insurer will ask about the roof whether you ask first or not. Asking first gives you the choice of answer. Talk to me before you list, and bring the permit.

More for Treasure Coast sellers: my guides on why a Port St. Lucie house is not selling, what Florida sellers must disclose, homestead portability, capital gains when you sell your home, selling an inherited home and whether to sell first or buy first.

Questions sellers ask about selling a house with an old roof

Can I sell my house in Florida with an old roof?

Yes. The roof's age matters mainly because your buyer has to insure the house, and under the AS IS contract the buyer can cancel during the inspection period if the property is unacceptable in the buyer's sole discretion. Replacing, inspecting, offering a credit and pricing for the roof are the four options to weigh.

Can an insurance company refuse to cover a house because the roof is old?

Not solely because of age if the roof is under 15 years old. For a roof 15 years or older, s. 627.7011(5) bars refusal solely because of roof age if an inspection by an inspector the insurer approves shows 5 or more years of useful life left. The statute does not say what happens below 5 years.

How old can a roof be for Citizens insurance?

Citizens wants documentation of at least five years of remaining useful life for shingle-type roofs older than 25 years and for tile, slate, clay, concrete or metal roofs older than 50 years. With less than five years left, it wants proof of a full replacement before a policy is written.

Can my buyer get Citizens coverage if the roof will be replaced after closing?

A September 11, 2025 Citizens bulletin allows an application on a purchase within 45 calendar days of the requested coverage date when a signed contract with a licensed contractor shows a full roof replacement within 30 calendar days of that date. The exception does not satisfy Citizens' other eligibility requirements, so the buyer's insurance agent should confirm how it applies.

If I repair part of my roof, do I have to replace the whole roof?

Under s. 553.844(5), if the roof was built, repaired or replaced to the 2007 Florida Building Code or later, only the repaired portion must meet the current code, even when 25 percent or more is repaired. A Citizens job aid uses a permit date of March 1, 2009 as the test for single-family homes and says a roof permitted before then with more than 25 percent of a section damaged will need to be replaced entirely; a licensed roofing contractor can assess yours.

Do I have to replace the roof under an AS IS contract?

The AS IS form does not obligate the seller to make repairs, so a repair happens only by written agreement, but the buyer can cancel during the inspection period, 15 days if the blank is left empty, and get the deposit back. If the buyer finds an open or needed roof permit, paragraph 12(c) requires the seller to cooperate, without having to spend money. A Florida real estate attorney can explain the form you sign.

Talk with William. Selling a home with an older roof? Send me the address and the date of your last roof permit, by call or text or through the contact page, and I will pull the permit record, show you which statute and Citizens thresholds your roof falls under, and lay out the replace, inspect, credit and price options side by side before you list. Call or text (772) 800-2274 or send a message.

General information, not legal, tax, lending or insurance advice, and not a guarantee of any sale, price or timeline. Insurer underwriting rules, Citizens bulletins, the My Safe Florida Home rules and building code editions change, and I did not verify roof replacement costs, permit fees, FHA or VA roof rules, or the AS IS contract's optional insurance rider; confirm with a licensed insurance agent, a licensed roofing contractor or inspector, the building department and a Florida real estate attorney. Statute, rule and market references are as reviewed on October 24, 2026. William Merchant, REALTOR®, RE/MAX Gold. Each RE/MAX office is independently owned and operated. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Sources

selling house old rooffour-point inspectioncitizens roof rulesroof insurance floridaport st lucie roof permit

William Merchant